by Calculated Risk on 8/15/2005 12:42:00 PM
Monday, August 15, 2005
Fleckenstein: Top in Place for Housing Market
Bill Fleckenstein writes the Contrarian Chronicles for MSN Money. This week he touches on housing:
'To get a feeling for the budding inventory problem in many previously hot markets, let's look at a less-hot market (via the following vignette from a reader of this column): A publicly held home-building company (which shall remain nameless) in Columbus, Ohio, has been buying back homes from financially distressed owners and reselling them, at reduced prices, only to folks who are approved for conventional mortgages. As the reader says: "The inventory of homes is growing -- including one cul-de-sac where a staggering 13 of 20 homes, all less than three years old, are already up for sale."'And on subprime mortgages:
'... a contact in the subprime-lending arena (lenders who specialize in making loans to borrowers with less-than-stellar credit records) suggests to me that it's becoming increasingly difficult for originators of subprime mortgages to sell them at a profit. Unless all of these are booked on the originator's own balance sheet, we'll start to see credit being cut off to the more marginal real-estate speculators -- the driving force, at the margin, behind the real-estate market.'Fleck concludes:
'...the macro winds have shifted, I believe, and none of those shifts has occurred in a way that is bullish for U.S. assets. Bottom line: It's my opinion that a top is being formed (or is already in place), both in the housing market and the stock market. That spells trouble for an economy built on the unsustainable strategy of trying to speculate our way to prosperity.'Fleck has been very bearish for a number of years. He was early (but correct) on the NASDAQ. And he has also been early on housing.
The housing market was very strong in the 2nd quarter. However it does appear that inventories are building and, as Fleck suggests, a top may be close.