by Calculated Risk on 8/16/2005 10:25:00 PM

The online world receives another treat today as Dr. Altig of Macroblog discusses the labor market with MaxSpeak's Max Sawicky and Tom Walker. Check out the WSJ Econoblog: Debating Job-Market 'Slack'.

I'd like to make my own small mundane contribution. In January I cut Mr. Bush some slack with regards to job creation during his first term. Bush's first term, with a net loss of 759K private sector jobs (a gain of 119K total jobs), has to be considered disappointing. However there were some reasons for the poor net job creation, the most compelling being that the economy was clearly overheated when Bush took office.

Looking forward there are no clear reasons why the US economy shouldn't see more normal job growth during Bush's 2nd term. With the economy adding 1.7 million working age people per year (according to the Census Bureau), the US economy should expect a minimum of 6.8 million net jobs created during Bush's 2nd term.

On the upside, the participation rate could increase and the economy could add close to 10 million net jobs. This is a realistic upside; the economy added 10.8 million jobs in Reagan's 2nd term and over 10 million jobs during each of Clinton's terms in office. The economy is larger today, so as a percentage gain, 10 million jobs would be less than for the Reagan or Clinton presidencies.

So for Bush's 2nd term, anything less than 6.8 Million net jobs will have to be considered poor. And anything above 10 million net jobs as excellent. Of course, in additional to the number of jobs, the quality of the jobs and real wage increases are also important measures.

For the quantity of jobs, the following graph provides a measurement tool for job growth during Bush's 2nd term.


Click on graph for larger image.

The blue line is for 10 million jobs created during Bush's 2nd term; the purple line for 6.8 million jobs. The insert shows net job creation for the first 6 months of the 2nd term - currently just below the blue line.

I will update the graph each month.