by Calculated Risk on 10/05/2009 11:38:00 AM

Senators John Cornyn and Charles Schumer appeared on ABC's 'This Week' with George Stephanopoulos and commented on the housing market: (CQ Transcript)

Sen. John Cornyn , R-Texas: [Senator] Johnny Isakson of Georgia has been championing the -- the tax credit for home purchases. Now it’s getting ready to expire, and it’s limited to $8,000 for first-time purchasers. His argument is, and I think he’s right, is that the housing inventories, or excess housing inventories are what are dampening the recovery. And I think he’s right.

A key problem for housing and the economy is that there are too many housing units compared to the number of households. However it is important to note that the two key categories of housing inventory are owner occupied units and rental units.

The so-called "first-time" homebuyer tax credit just moves people from renting to owning, and doesn't reduce the overall number of excess housing units. As I've noted before, the tax credit policy will push the rental vacancy rate above 11% soon.

And how will that impact all the "accidental landlords"? From Shahien Nasiripour at the HuffPost: Unable To Sell Their Houses, Millions Of Homeowners Are Turning Into Landlords:

[A] growing number of homeowners ... have become landlords, often reluctantly, as they struggle to sell during one of the worst housing markets in recent memory. The most prominent example may be U.S. Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner, who after failing to sell his $1.6 million home in a New York City suburb found tenants instead.

By just shuffling housholds from renting to owning, the tax credit will force some of these accidental landlords into foreclosure.

And although a higher vacancy rate and lower rents is good news for renters, this will also lead to more apartment defaults, higher default rates for apartment CMBS, and more losses for small and regional banks.

Since the tax credit is poorly targeted and inefficient, it might be hurting the economy more than helping. And it does nothing to reduce the excess inventory problem.

And from Senator Schumer:

Sen. Charles E. Schumer , D-N.Y. : ... I’d be for extending the housing tax credit, which has helped get the housing market out of the severe depression it was in.

The new home market is definitely in a depression, and will not recover until the excess housing inventory is reduced. However most of the tax credit was aimed at the existing home market - and existing home sales are at about a normal level (not depressed), although the mix is skewed toward the lower end and distressed sales (not a healthy market).

Note: no one should expect the new home market to recover to the level of the boom years (I wrote about the new home housing market his weekend: The Impact of the Declining Homeownership Rate)

And finally from the host:

George Stephanopoulos: So we have agreement: extend unemployment benefits, extend health care benefits for people who are unemployed, and extend the housing tax credit.

I don't think there is agreement. The Obama administration is talking about "extending the safety net", and no one can argue the tax credit is part of the safety net.

If Senators Cornyn and Isakson want additional stimulus, then providing more aid to the unemployed (13 weeks won't last long), or aid to the states, would be far more effective use of money than the homebuyer tax credit. More jobs will create more households - and more households is the key to the housing market.