by Calculated Risk on 5/18/2010 12:45:00 PM

From Cleveland Fed President Sandra Pianalto: Forecasting in Uncertain Times

As we are all aware, we're emerging from the deepest and longest recession since the Great Depression. Our models would tell us that the deeper the downturn in the economy, the more rapid the recovery. You've probably heard this referred to as a V-shaped recovery.

However, my outlook is that our journey out of this deep recession will be a slow one because we face two primary headwinds that I expect will temper growth for awhile. The first is the effect of prolonged unemployment, and the second is a heightened sense of caution on the part of consumers and businesspeople.
...
About half of those who are currently unemployed have been out of work for at least six months, and the longer someone is out of work, the harder it is to find a job. In the 1982 recession, which was another severe recession, the average duration of unemployment peaked at 21 weeks, but today the average is already over 30 weeks—a record high. Research also tells us that workers lose valuable skills during long spells of unemployment, and that some jobs simply don't return.
...
The second powerful headwind in this recession is a heightened sense of caution, driven by a deep uncertainty about where the "new normal" or baseline might be. A whole generation of Americans who began their working careers in the mid-1980s had experienced only long periods of prosperity punctuated by just two very brief downturns. Those experiences encouraged an expectation for relatively smooth growth. Now everyone's expectations have shifted as a result of this long and deep recession.

People's attitudes about their own prospects have fundamentally changed. In a recent survey by Ohio's Xavier University, 60 percent of those polled believe attaining the American dream is harder for this generation than ones before. And nearly 70 percent think it will be even more difficult for their children. Many people are now just aiming for “financial security” as their American dream
...
Businesses are also cautious. Business leaders base many decisions on forecasts, and they tell me that they are attaching the same high degree of uncertainty around their projections as I am. Most business leaders say that they’re not planning significant hiring until there’s more clarity about how the recovery is going to progress and about policies relating to health care, energy, the environment, and taxes. This caution translates into fewer job opportunities, fewer equipment purchases, fewer building projects—and on and on.

These two factors—overall caution and the effects of labor market damage—lead me to an outlook for relatively subdued output growth through this year and next, with unemployment rates that decline only gradually.

We already know that a "V-shaped" recovery is off the table. Researchers at the San Francisco Fed argued yesterday for a recovery between a "U" and a "V", see The Shape of Things to Come, however those researchers focused on GDP, and I'd suggest GDI, employment and real personal income less transfer payments all suggest an even more sluggish recovery than GDP.

Also I'd add residential investment to Pianalto's two "headwinds". Usually housing is a key engine of growth in a recovery - for both GDP and employment - and this time any contribution from housing will be muted for some time.